Collective code ownership is an important factor of XP

 Strong code ownership, weak code ownership and collective code ownership are the three main categories according to Martine Fowler, "Chief Scientist" of ThoughtWorks. 


  • Strong code ownership breaks a codebase into modules and is assigned to one developer. Developers are only allowed to make changes to modules they own.
  • Weak code ownership is modules that are assigned to owners but are allowed to be changed by other people.
  • Collective code ownership abandons any notion of individual ownership of modules. The code base is owned by the entire team and anyone may make changes anywhere. 




Problems of Individual Code Ownership

Among the cases I have known, the teamwork is mostly divided according to features. For example, Developer A is responsible for Feature A, and Developer B is responsible for Feature B. One will not take care of the other one's responsibilities. Consequently, a lot of problems are caused.


1. No cooperation within the team.

Since one is only responsible for the module/feature s/he is developing, no one knows/understands the other one's work. It means cooperation and communication are not much.


2. It is not easy to cultivate team spirit.

No cooperation means no teamwork. Besides, there are always developers who claim challenging tasks/bugs and ones who claim easy ones. This will motivate neither of the two kinds.


3. Redundant features are developed.

This is also caused by a lack of communication. Redundant work is a waste of human resources.


4. Knowledge cannot be shared within the team.

When developing modules/features, a certain knowledge-silo is build up. Because each one is only taking care of his/her responsibility and no cooperation/ communication, the accumulated knowlesge cannot be shared with others.


5. It is very risky as only the one who developed the feature know it. Once the developer leaves, it will cause problems and affect the company.

This is the last thing a company would like to see. If the module owner leaves, no one else can take over his/her module due to the individual code ownership.


Therefore, collective code ownership is practiced in Extreme Programming. It is to bridge the barrier within a team. Each module should be understood by at least two developers who back up with each other, and so knowledge could be passed around and developers can come and go without causing problems.

Collective Code Ownership

The code owned by the entire team and anyone can make changes to it. The benefit of collective code ownership is obvious.

  • Knowledge can be shared.
  • Code style can be unified.
  • Interdependency rather than too much responsibility on individuals.
  • ...

However, there are always two sides to a coin. Collective code ownership makes it difficult to hold a certain developer accountable. When everyone is responsible, no one is responsible.



Conclusion

Strong code ownership and weak code ownership are individual code ownership that module owners are responsible for their own modules. The only difference lies in the weak code ownership allows other developers to change the codebase while the owner has to look after it.  The choice has more to do with the team dynamics. Our team, ZenTao, prefers collective code ownership, particularly in the context of Extreme Programming.


Reference

1. https://martinfowler.com/bliki/CodeOwnership.html

2. https://tobeagile.com/2017/09/13/collective-code-ownership/

3. https://dzone.com/articles/collective-code-ownership-in-agile-teams

4.  https://martinfowler.com/bliki/CodeOwnership.html

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ZenTao project management software: an Open source Scrum tool and self-hosted solution

Image
  ZenTao project management software: Open source Scrum tool and self-hosted solution What is ZenTao? How ZenTao workflow fits in Scrum ZenTao is a Scrum tool for software developers, teams, companies, remote developers, and freelancers. It offers a solution to do remote collaboration work or even locally. ZenTao has an open-source version and can be self-hosted easily.  ZenTao features ZenTao Biz includes the features as below, PHP Language Written Email&Webhook Notification Backlog Management Sprint and Task Bug Tracking Roadmap Burndown Kanban SaaS Self Hosting Gantt Customized Workflow LDAP MS Word/Excel Import&Export Attendance GIT/SVN Repo Effort Log Wiki Library Role Management API Calendar  Timesheet Dashboard: Where you could find everything related to you Dashboard Gantt: You could manage task dependencies here and view them by various groups Gantt Report: Tremendous kind of report you could check to evaluate  Workload report Wiki Library:...
Read more

Why Zombie Scrum Teams Don’t Ship Fast

Image
  In environments with Zombie Scrum, people don’t understand why it’s important to ship fast. When you   ask them, they respond with a shrug. Or with a dismissive smile, because “that can’t possibly work for a product or organization as complex as ours”. For them, shipping fast is only possible for small and inconsequential products or for huge tech companies like LinkedIn, Facebook, and Etsy. Even if they’d want to, the investment would simply be too large. It’s more convenient to keep batching many updates into large, infrequent releases. Honestly, this is not very different from seeing the appeal in a healthy lifestyle but refusing to do the frequent workouts to get there. Signs to watch for Regardless of how much work Scrum Teams complete within a Sprint, features are batched into large quarterly or yearly releases. Releases are “all hands”-affairs where people clear their schedule for the evening and the next day(s) to address issues caused by the release. “That doesn’t w...
Read more

Top 6 FREE and Open Source Project Management Systems in 2021

Image
  1- ProjeQtOr ProjeQtOr is a free open source project management software grouping in a single tool all the features needed to organize your projects. It is simple, easy to use while covering a maximum of project management features. ProjeQtOr is designed as a collaborative tool,  available in Web mode, and so requires the setup of a Web server.  However, the installation is easy and automated as much as possible. To setup and run ProjeQtOr, a simple PHP / MySql stack is needed, you can use your favorite stack (EasyPHP, ZEND, WAMP, XAMPP). Highlights Multilingual (14 languages) Cross-Platform. 100% collaborative (web based). Web 2.0 user interface. 2- ZenTao ZenTao  is an open source project management software whose main features are product management, project management, QA management, document management, bug management and todo management. It is a professional Application Lifecycel Mangement(ALM) , covering the core process of software development. It also...
Read more